Found something off?
Mental Drafting is new, and I know some prompts are awkward and some scores are off. I’m planning to come back to it, and reports like these are what I’ll work from. A prompt that made no sense, a card you named that should have counted, a score that felt wrong: tell me here.
Where this came from
The format is borrowed, with admiration, from Krillion, the daily dive by kp: seven prompts, a short clock, and the rarer your answer the deeper you sink. This is that idea pointed at one very large card pool. Go and play the original.
How is rarity judged?
Nobody keeps a record of which cards players think of first, so this estimates it. A card counts as well known if it is played a lot in Commander (its EDHREC rank), has been reprinted often, or has ever been banned or restricted. Your score comes from where your card sits among everything that fits the prompt. The estimate is reliable about the obvious answers and rougher about the forgotten ones, and it leans towards a Commander player's idea of famous.
That is only the starting point. Every answer played here is counted (the card and the prompt, nothing about who gave it), and as answers accumulate the scores follow what people actually name instead of the estimate.
Where do the prompts come from?
Each prompt is a real Scryfall search, put together from parts (a colour, a type, something the card does, a range of sets) and kept only if between 500 and 5,000 cards fit. Fewer than that and there is no room for a clever answer; more and almost anything would do. After you answer, the search itself is shown so you can see everything that fit. There are 75 hands a day and every player gets the same ones in the same order.
Card data from MTGJSON; card art from Scryfall, credited to its artist on each card. Mental Drafting is unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Fan Content Policy. Not approved or endorsed by Wizards. Portions of the materials used are property of Wizards of the Coast. © Wizards of the Coast LLC.